Half Caff K Cups That You Should Try In 2021

By: | Updated: April 20, 2021

Our website is supported by our users. We sometimes earn affiliate links when you click through the affiliate links on our website. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

To caffeine or not to caffeine that is the question. Whether it’s noble to have coffee in the evening and to lie awake at night from the coffee. Yes, I’m your regular dime store Shakespeare using one of the gems of literature to represent the coffee dilemma.

The answer to our current dilemma is half caff K cups. There are a ton of reasons you want them. Enjoying their taste and flavor, trying to wean off caffeine, or just about something else. Maybe it’s just coffee cravings of the evening, without the worry of ruining your sleep.

Half caff is a good way to enjoy the coffee while cutting off the caffeine content. There’s our compromise candidate for when we don’t want caffeine but can’t go full decaf either. I’m possibly being harsh here, half caff coffee is a good beverage in its own right.

Top 7 Half Caff K Cups To Enjoy

Comparison Chart

Fresh Roasted Coffee, Swiss Water Half-Caf Sumatra, Organic Fair Trade Kosher RFA, K-Cup Compatible, 72 Pods
World’s Best Half Caff Dark Roast Coffee 24ct. Recyclable Single Serve Dark Roast Coffee Pods – 100% Arabica Coffee California Roasted, KCup Compatible
Folgers Half Caff Coffee, Keurig K-Cups, 18 Count
Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC, Organic Half-Caf Coffee Pod Variety Pack, 72 Count
Skinnygirl Half Caff Coffee Pods for Keurig K Cups Brewers, Reduced Caffeine Medium Roast Coffee in Single Serve Cups, 24 Count
Green Mountain Half-caff Hazelnut K-cups
Keurig, Green Mountain Coffee, Half-Caff, 24 K-Cup Packs for Keurig Brewing System (Packaging May Vary)

1. Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC, Swiss Water Half Caf Organic Sumatra Coffee Pods — Best Gourmet Coffee

Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC has an excellent range of half caff and decaf K cups. I chose the Sumatra Coffee Pods for their overall great taste. The range is also available in other flavors and coffee origin locations. You can have your pick from

  • Colombian Half Caff
  • Ethiopian Sidamo Half Caf (Organic and awesome, give it a shot!)
  • Indian Monsoon Malabar Half Caf
  • Mexican Half Caf Organic
  • Peruvian Half Caf Organic
  • Sumatra Half Caf Organic

Sumatra Half Caf K cups are made from single-origin coffee sourced from Aceh, Sumatra in Indonesia. The coffee is made using a blend of the company’s regular Sumatra coffee and decaf Sumatra coffee. Half of each is mixed to reach the half-caf variant. 

The combination works beautifully well in retaining the taste and notes of rich Sumatra coffee. The astringent decaf flavor is not noticeable, which makes it better. We can like decaf, but I don’t think anyone likes that weird astringent sense. Instead, you get more welcome earthy and chocolate notes. 

Coffee Highlights

  • Certified from USDA Organic, Fair Trade, Rainforest Alliance, OU Kosher
  • K cups made from #5 BPA-free recyclable plastic. Not the best option, but good enough
  • Single-origin Sumatra coffee
  • Medium roast
  • Baker’s chocolate and earthy taste notes
  • 100% Arabica

2. World’s Best Half Caff Dark Roast Coffee K Cups — Best Dark Roast

“World’s Best Half Caff” is a pretty strong claim, even if it’s hidden in the name. It’s pretty decent coffee, which is why it is on this list. However, the packaging and marketing raise more red flags than Stalin in a parade. 

For one, naming your half caff “World’s best half caff” is just cheesy. I don’t mind it going into marketing, but putting it in the name seems more like an attention grabber. 

Their box proudly claims in a nice, bright green background “Save the earth, one cup at a time”. No, you’re not saving the world by using #5 plastic K cups. To save the earth one cup at a time, the right way is to not use that single-use plastic cup. It’s recyclable, and that’s the bare minimum anyone should be doing.

Yes, I know there are tons of businesses and companies that won’t even take the trouble of using recyclable plastics. But let’s not pretend it’s a favor to the earth. K cup plastic waste is a real problem. As people who enjoy these cups, we should take real responsibility and action rather than say Hallelujah to non-solution.

Damn, I got triggered and worked myself up with that rant. Anyways, the dark roast tastes good enough to be allowed onto this list and inflict the world with that rant.

Coffee Highlights

  • Good dark roast
  • Uses #5 BPA-free recyclable plastic
  • Also available in Caramel and Hazelnut flavors (medium roast)
  • Good flavor

3. Folgers Half Caff Coffee — Best Overall

As I said earlier, it is a bit of a surprise for me that Folgers turned out as the best in this category. They’re not bad, but besting gourmet options is quite unusual. This is a blend of regular and decaf done well enough to have a drink with a nice body and aroma. 

What makes this K cup the best is that it’s rich! And deliciously so. This is a medium roast coffee with excellent flavor and taste.

Coffee Highlights

  • Rich coffee with great taste
  • Mix of regular and decaf coffee
  • Good blend
  • Medium roast

4. Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC, Half Caf Coffee Pod Variety Pack — Best Variety Pack

Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC has two entries on our list. The first one was for individual packs and this one is dedicated to their variety pack. They have quite a great range of great-tasting coffee available. So, it makes sense to give the variety pack a shot. 

Most of the options in the pack are single-origin coffees from some of the most renowned locations. Highlights of the variety pack are coffees from Sumatra, Ethiopia, Mexico, and Peru. Plus, they’re organic and are certified fair trade and for several other characteristics. Blends in this variety pack are made from excellent gourmet coffee.

Coffee Highlights

  • Certified from USDA Organic, Fair Trade, Rainforest Alliance, OU Kosher
  • K cups made from #5 BPA-free recyclable plastic
  • Single origin coffee

5. Skinnygirl Half Caff coffee Single Serve Cups — Excellent Blend

Skinnygirl Half Caff gives you a great tasting cup of coffee in an expert blend. The coffee doesn’t have any artificial flavors or sweeteners. It relies on the goodness of the blend and the coffee and it fairs pretty well. 

Coffee Highlights

  • Rainforest Alliance certified
  • No added flavors or sweeteners
  • Medium roast
  • Good blend

6. Green Mountain Half-caff Hazelnut K-cups — Best Flavor

Green Mountain cups is a brand that everyone who’s used a Keurig K cup is familiar with. They never disappoint with their coffee and indeed it matches well with their favorite coffee brewer. The hazelnut flavor takes amazingly well to the half-caff. 

Overall, the coffee has a good body and aroma. And together with the touch of hazelnut, the taste is well-worth praise. If you’re on the fence about half caff, start with this one.

Coffee Highlights

  • Medium roast coffee
  • Hazelnut flavor
  • Good body and taste
  • Excellent for those new to half caf

7. Green Mountain Half Caff K Cups — Best Body

Here’s another one of Green Mountain Half Caff K cups you can love. The blend is a result of excellent coffee, blended in perfect ratios of regular and decaf. The blend is careful to keep all of the goodness of coffee in the cup while removing half the caffeine. It succeeds spectacularly at it, and the cup is a delight.

The cup has a good body and uses it to its full advantage. This pod brews a satisfying cup of coffee, one which you can love and enjoy.

Coffee Highlights

  • Medium roast coffee
  • Excellent body
  • Good taste
  • Organic and fair trade

Things To Know When Buying Half Caff Pods

Half Caff K Cups – How Much Caffeine?

K cups are available through several companies, blends, flavors, and coffee origins. As such, there can’t be a single, right answer. However, we can make estimations like how much caffeine in a cup of coffee

It is estimated that the average K cup will deliver 100mg of caffeine for a regular 8oz cup of coffee. We are making estimates here because there are strong K cups that can go very high in caffeine. 

Most half-caffs are made with an equal mix of regular and decaf coffee. In a way, these are half decaf K cups! Though there is little value to the term half decaf. The caffeine content for an average K cup can be 50-70mg, for a standard 8oz serving. 

Storing And Managing Your K Cups

Did your pod go slightly over the “best before” date? That’s not much to worry about because K cups don’t expire for a fairly long time. So, a couple of weeks after the date should be fine. They will lose taste and flavor the longer they’re kept beyond their date. 

It will also depend on the additives used because things like dried milk will go bad faster. The best thing is to store your K cups in a cool and dry place without sunlight. Going slightly beyond the best before date should be okay, but be careful and discard any damaged cups. If they taste or smell funny even within their use-by date, to the bin they go.

Rounding Up For The Best

The pursuit of the right half caff K cups can bring you to great options. This is a relatively smaller niche, so there isn’t the usual variety of K cups and flavors available. However, it is popular enough to have excellent options. You can get everything from flavored to gourmet coffee with these K cups.

Our top choice here is the Folgers Half Caff K cups. A close runner up is Fresh Roasted Coffee with their excellent half caff cups. If you want some flavor, pick the Green Mountain Half Caff Hazelnut K cups.

by Joakim
Joakim is a coffee connoisseur who loves all types of coffee, no matter the type or region of origin. He loves writing about his coffee experience, sharing with readers the tastes, methods of making, and more.